March 28, 2017

Building Smart: LJ’s Design Institute Inspires Spaces for the Future | Library by Design, Spring 2012

By Rebecca T. Miller, with Elizabeth J. Allee and Louise Schaper

If you want to learn about great library design, step into Phoenix’s Burton Barr Central Library. That was apparent to the participants in LJ’s daylong Design Institute, held there November 11, 2011.

As they explored the stunning five-story icon, opened in 1995 and designed by bruderDWL architects, attendees found the perfect complement to the ideas that came out of the day. And did those ideas flow! Some 90 librarians, architects, and vendors gathered to talk about how to build for flexibility in uncertain times and brainstorm solutions to a handful of design challenges (see:  Design Institute: Six Space Challenges from Six Libraries).

Building for change

As the culture, and budgets, shift quickly, so do service models. A big pressure, said Bruce Flynn, principal at Barker Rinker Seacat Architecture, is the rise of mobile. “The challenge,” he said, “will be to keep up with technological change in a fluid way.”

But the buildings, all agreed, can’t be expensive to change with the tides. So, talk turned to partitions. To create a sense of a room within a larger space, said Louise Schaper, project leader on LJ’s New Landmark Libraries and former executive director of the Fayetteville Public Library, AR, boundaries can be created with temporary walls made from fabric or by hanging strips of plastic or other material.

Sometimes, though, it’s not about dividing space; it’s about where you put people who need and want to do things together, including the growing senior population.

Creating “adjacencies” that support cross-­generational use, is increasingly important, noted Joe Huberty, partner at Engberg Anderson. That connectivity can enhance play, even for adults. “Let’s be the place everyone wants to be and hang out,” said Huberty.

“Everyone relates to having an experience,” said ­Flynn. In the academic arena, said Dan Meehan, principal at HBM Architecture, that trend is reflected in a move “from a collection-based space toward a collective, resource-based gathering space.”

Eye on the next generation

Just such dynamic, collaborative space is modeled in Chicago Public Library’s YOUmedia teen space at the Harold Washington Library Center. “The vision supports collaborative space and individual space,” said Amy Eshleman, then coleader of YOUmedia and now program leader for education at the Urban Libraries Council, where she is in charge of grants to replicate the YOUmedia model in other libraries. The space itself is in one room, she said, which is challenging because of noise but successful because the kids can see one another—“that it was designed as a big open space is really important,” she said. There kids also create stories in many media formats. This reflects content-driven changes, “from consuming to creating,” said Tony Rohr, GouldEvans national managing principal.

With this in mind, librarians “need to plan for space that is not programmed,” said Denelle Wrightson, Dewberry’s director of library architecture, “and build in budget for changing the program.”

Letting the work patrons want to doshape the library program, and the space design, is perhaps the ultimate recognition of whom libraries serve. That means librarians have to learn more about their patrons and what they want; both data and observation can help. “When you plan a college campus,” said Dennis Humphries, principal at Humphries Poli ­Architects, “you don’t put down paths. Instead, you let people walk and then put down paths.”

Other trends explored throughout the day included the need to supply enough power via raised floors or, as is the case in the Barr Library, by bringing the power source down from the ceiling. Also noted was the rise of USB power towers, increasingly common in large airports. And bigger picture: look to other industries for ideas and pull in expertise from uncommon sources to innovate on projects.

Design Institute Slideshow

Photos by Mark Peterman/Getty Images and Kevin Henegan

Slide 1
The central downtown library’s striking exterior, the site of the Design Institute.
Slide 2
Louise Schaper chats with then Scottsdale PL director Rita Hamilton, now at Phoenix, and Phoenix’s former director Toni Garvey.
Slide 3
The crowd is engaged during a morning panel.
Slide 4
Fred Schutmaat from Jasper
Slide 5
Rick Mason from 3M
Slide 6
Joe Huberty (l.) and Bill Williams from Engberg Anderson network at breakfast, and
Slide 7
Dan Meehan from HBM shares project info.
Slide 8
Attendees sign up for challenges.
Slide 9
Tech Logic’s Joe Libman assists interested librarians.
Slide 10
and Barker Rinker Seacat’s Bruce Flynn
Slide 11
in the second panel on new skills and content creation, Humphries Poli’s Dennis Humphries (l.), Chicago PL’s Amy Eshleman, and GouldEvans’s Tony Rohr enlighten the crowd
Slide 12
Dewberry’s Denelle Wrightson (l.) and consultant Kim van der Veen offer their expertise
Slide 13
Demco’s Stephen Gower and Janet Nelson showcase new products
Slide 14
vendors Diane Strohm and Bill Macal represent AGATI
Slide 15
Julie Moore-Miller and Jaclyn Guiliano hand out literature for TMC
Slide 16
Peter Schoen presents Lyngsoe Systems’ designs
Slide 17
Worden’s Linda Visscher offers furniture ideas
Slide 18
Design challenges put attendees to work: at Humphries Poli’s challenge for Black Hawk Quad Cities Library, attendees rethink the project against the Phoenix skyline;
Slide 19
GouldEvans’s Idea Kit cards come into play for Clark College, WA;
Slide 20
and HBM’s Dan Meehan and Renee Moldovansky encourage teams to re-create designs for Jackson District Library, MI

This article was published in Library Journal. Subscribe today and save up to 35% off the regular subscription rate.

Start Planning the Library of the Future
Coding Program WorkshopHosted by Library Journal in partnership with Columbus Metropolitan Library on—in its newly renovated Main Library—our May 5 installment of this day-long library building and design event will bring you the latest trends in library design.
5 Essentials For Creating Community-Centered Libraries
Coding Program WorkshopThis deep dive online course beginning on April 19 is designed to impact all staff and stakeholders from front line staff to the director’s chair. We’ll provide a step-by-step guide to turn your community engagement ideas into a powerful roadmap for setting direction, measuring outcomes, and leading your community.